I wanted a mantle. Our fireplace was all naked.
First, I looked into buying a ready-made mantle. There were some really beautiful ones out there (Like this one). But, we'd spent a bunch of money on home improvements, and I wasn't really feeling like spending a ton of money on buying a mantle.
So I started looking at less expensive options at the Home Depot and the like. Didn't really find anything that was that interesting - a lot of the options were too ornate or just not my style.
Then, it hit me: Craigslist.

I found this nice mantle for $50. It was far away, but I convinced my very nice husband to go fetch it for me.
When we got home, I realized that we had a big problem. I can't measure, or can't pay attention to measurements, because it was at least a full foot too short for our fireplace. Sigh.
I put it aside for a while, and thought about what to do about it. Considered adding blocks to the bottom, but I didn't love that idea. It involved an awful lot of building. And at this point in our home improvements, we were feeling pretty lazy.
Then I finally got tired of having the mantle in a corner of the living room, and decided to reconfigure it. Instead of being a shelf with 2 legs, I thought it could be made entirely into a shelf mantle. We took the legs, cut them down by a couple of inches, and put them side-by-side under the shelf. We mounted that to the wall above the marble surround. Then I got some little 2" MDF and trimmed the mantle out - I had to cover up the big ugly cuts through the center.
Then, I had to think about ornamentation. There's usually a flowery bit or something in the middle of the cutouts of the mantle. But, for me, bunny heads were the answer. Now I have a mantle that makes me happy every time I look at it!

